Two Big Mistakes To Avoid When You Date

How do you greet someone on a first date?

Do you keep things polite with a handshake? Presume a certain level of affection and go for a hug? Add a kiss on the cheek? Or maybe avoid the issue altogether and stick with an awkward smile?

I genuinely don’t know the answer! There have been times when I’ve gone for the handshake and my date has gone for the hug. Another time when I went for the hug and my date’s reaction was comparable to the fear response of a fainting goat. Once, we were both so uncertain that we just decided to fist-bump.

Dating as a young Catholic can be complicated.

Some people marry their high school sweetheart and avoid the young adult dating scene altogether. Others (myself included) date a number of different people as they navigate young adulthood.

There’s no one-size-fits-all formula. Yet while there isn’t a single right way to date, there are definitely wrong ways to date. Two approaches, in particular, are constant culprits for starting a dating relationship on the wrong foot.


In an attempt to woo your prospective partner, you go all out. You organize a full day of activities or take them to a restaurant so fancy you pay $12 just for the table water.

Whatever you do, you go ‘all in’—you aren’t leaving even a shred of doubt in your date’s mind about your romantic intentions.

The problem with the ‘all in’ approach is that it can create a lot of unnecessary pressure—for both parties.

The person who plans that date can end up feeling like they need to constantly impress the other person. The unsuspecting recipient of an ‘all in’ date can be left feeling uncomfortable about the amount of time (and often money) that has been spent on him/her.

Furthermore, when an ‘all in” date doesn’t go well, it can turn into a kind of date-imprisonment for either or both of the parties. It’s hard to politely excuse yourself from a situation when you are only one hour into a four-hour romantic river cruise.


At the opposite end of the dating spectrum from the ‘all in’ is the ‘chill.” The ‘chill’ approach to dating typically involves inviting someone to a nearby couch, park or group setting to, well, ‘chill.’

While your goal in taking the chill approach might be to create a casual, low-pressure setting for the date, the problem with ‘chill’ is that it often leaves the other person with no freaking idea about what is going on.

You might be perfectly comfortable in your sweatpants, but they are probably wondering what you plan on doing for the next hour, whether you’re going to share your bag of Doritos and most importantly, whether the two of you are even on a date.

The ‘chill’ approach to dating can also cause undue hurt or confusion where the other person doesn’t understand your intentions. They might assume that your invitation to “grab coffee together” is a purely platonic opportunity to sample the varieties of almond milk available at your local café, while you intended it to be the start of a dating relationship.

Finally, the chill approach to dating can be perceived as a lack of effort on your part. The person you’re asking out probably doesn’t expect a 4-stop tour of the vineyards in your region, but I’m sure they want to feel like you care about getting to know them.


As you’ve probably figured out, the solution is a balance between the two extremes. If you want to start dating someone, be intentional. Put a bit of effort into planning your dates and make it clear to the other person that you are, in fact, asking them on a date. One method that I’ve found works well is to use some variation of the phrase “I’d like to take you on a date.”

However, try to keep things relaxed. Your goal for the first few dates should be to create a low-pressure setting where the two of you can start getting to know each other. You can always postpone the hot-air balloon ride until you’re a bit more serious!


Samuel Brebner is a Catholic speaker and writer from the sunny shores of New Zealand. He works for Real Talk, a Catholic organization that speaks in high schools across Australia and New Zealand on the topics of love, sex and relationships. He writes to encourage young people to be all that God created them to be. For more of Sam’s writing, visit his blog

Related Resources

How to Find Your Soulmate without Losing Your Soul
By: Jason and Crystalina Evert
The Dating Blueprint
By: Jason Evert
Saint John Paul the Great: His Five Loves
By: Jason Evert
If You Really Loved Me
By: Jason Evert
Eclipse of the Body
By: Christopher West
Pure Love (Catholic version)
By: Jason Evert
Pure Womanhood (Catholic version)
By: Crystalina Evert
Pure Manhood (Catholic version)
By: Jason Evert
Purity 365
By: Jason Evert
The Dating Project Bundle